| 1860 | | | | Willie Park Sr. (ESC) |
| 1861 | | | | Old Tom Morris (ESC) |
| 1862 | | | | Old Tom Morris (ESC) |
| 1863 | | | | Willie Park Sr. (ESC) |
| 1864 | | | | Old Tom Morris (ESC) |
| 1865 | | | | Andrew Strath (ESC) |
| 1866 | | | | Willie Park Sr. (ESC) |
| 1867 | | | | Old Tom Morris (ESC) |
| 1868 | | | | Young Tom Morris (ESC) |
| 1869 | | | | Young Tom Morris (ESC) |
| 1870 | | | | Young Tom Morris (ESC) |
| 1872 | | | | Young Tom Morris (ESC) |
| 1873 | | | | Tom Kidd (ESC) |
| 1874 | | | | Mungo Park (ESC) |
| 1875 | | | | Willie Park Sr. (ESC) |
| 1876 | | | | Bob Martin (ESC) |
| 1877 | | | | Jamie Anderson (ESC) |
| 1878 | | | | Jamie Anderson (ESC) |
| 1879 | | | | Jamie Anderson (ESC) |
| 1880 | | | | Bob Ferguson (ESC) |
| 1881 | | | | Bob Ferguson (ESC) |
| 1882 | | | | Bob Ferguson (ESC) |
| 1883 | | | | Willie Fernie (ESC) |
| 1884 | | | | Jack Simpson (ESC) |
| 1885 | | | | Bob Martin (ESC) |
| 1886 | | | | David Brown (ESC) |
| 1887 | | | | Willie Park Jr. (ESC) |
| 1888 | | | | Jack Burns (ESC) |
| 1889 | | | | Willie Park Jr. (ESC) |
| 1890 | | | | John Ball (ING) |
| 1891 | | | | Hugh Kirkaldy (ESC) |
| 1892 | | | | Harold Hilton (ING) |
| 1893 | | | | William Auchterlonie (ESC) |
| 1894 | | | | John Henry Taylor (ING) |
| 1895 | | | Horace Rawlins (ING) | John Henry Taylor (ING) |
| 1896 | | | James Foulis (ESC) | Harry Vardon (ING) |
| 1897 | | | Joe Lloyd (ING) | Harold Hilton (ING) |
| 1898 | | | Fred Herd (ESC) | Harry Vardon (ING) |
| 1899 | | | Willie Smith (ESC) | Harry Vardon (ING) |
| 1900 | | | Harry Vardon (ING) | John Henry Taylor (ING) |
| 1901 | | | Willie Anderson (ESC) | James Braid (ESC) |
| 1902 | | | Laurie Auchterlonie (ESC) | Sandy Herd (ESC) |
| 1903 | | | Willie Anderson (ESC) | Harry Vardon (ING) |
| 1904 | | | Willie Anderson (ESC) | Jack White (ESC) |
| 1905 | | | Willie Anderson (ESC) | James Braid (ESC) |
| 1906 | | | Alex Smith (ESC) | James Braid (ESC) |
| 1907 | | | Alec Ross (ESC) | Arnaud Massy (FRA) |
| 1908 | | | Fred McLeod (ESC) | James Braid (ESC) |
| 1909 | | | George Sargent (ING) | John Henry Taylor (ING) |
| 1910 | | | Alex Smith (ESC) | James Braid (ESC) |
| 1911 | | | John McDermott (EU) | Harry Vardon (ING) |
| 1912 | | | John McDermott (EU) | Ted Ray (ING) |
| 1913 | | | Francis Ouimet (EU) | John Henry Taylor (ING) |
| 1914 | | | Walter Hagen (EU) | Harry Vardon (ING) |
| 1915 | | | Jerome Travers (EU) | |
| 1916 | | Jim Barnes (ING) | Chick Evans (EU) | |
| 1919 | | Jim Barnes (ING) | Walter Hagen (EU) | |
| 1920 | | Jock Hutchison (ESC) | Ted Ray (ING) | George Duncan (ESC) |
| 1921 | | Walter Hagen (EU) | Jim Barnes (ING) | Jock Hutchison (EU) |
| 1922 | | Gene Sarazen (EU) | Gene Sarazen (EU) | Walter Hagen (EU) |
| 1923 | | Gene Sarazen (EU) | Bobby Jones (EU) | Arthur Havers (ING) |
| 1924 | | Walter Hagen (EU) | Cyril Walker (ING) | Walter Hagen (EU) |
| 1925 | | Walter Hagen (EU) | Willie Macfarlane (ESC) | Jim Barnes (EU) |
| 1926 | | Walter Hagen (EU) | Bobby Jones (EU) | Bobby Jones (EU) |
| 1927 | | Walter Hagen (EU) | Tommy Armour (EU) | Bobby Jones (EU) |
| 1928 | | Leo Diegel (EU) | Johnny Farrell (EU) | Walter Hagen (EU) |
| 1929 | | Leo Diegel (EU) | Bobby Jones (EU) | Walter Hagen (EU) |
| 1930 | | Tommy Armour (ESC) | Bobby Jones (EU) | Bobby Jones (EU) |
| 1931 | | Tom Creavy (EU) | Billy Burke (EU) | Tommy Armour (EU) |
| 1932 | | Olin Dutra (EU) | Gene Sarazen (EU) | Gene Sarazen (EU) |
| 1933 | | Gene Sarazen (EU) | Johnny Goodman (EU) | Denny Shute (EU) |
| 1934 | Horton Smith (EU) | Paul Runyan (EU) | Olin Dutra (EU) | Henry Cotton (ING) |
| 1935 | Gene Sarazen (EU) | Johnny Revolta (EU) | Sam Parks Jr. (EU) | Alf Perry (ING) |
| 1936 | Horton Smith (EU) | Denny Shute (EU) | Tony Manero (EU) | Alf Padgham (ING) |
| 1937 | Byron Nelson (EU) | Denny Shute (EU) | Ralph Guldahl (EU) | Henry Cotton (ING) |
| 1938 | Henry Picard (EU) | Paul Runyan (EU) | Ralph Guldahl (EU) | Reg Whitcombe (ING) |
| 1939 | Ralph Guldahl (EU) | Henry Picard (EU) | Byron Nelson (EU) | Dick Burton (ING) |
| 1940 | Jimmy Demaret (EU) | Byron Nelson (EU) | Lawson Little (EU) | |
| 1941 | Craig Wood (EU) | Vic Ghezzi (EU) | Craig Wood (EU) | |
| 1942 | Byron Nelson (EU) | Sam Snead (EU) | | |
| 1944 | | Bob Hamilton (EU) | | |
| 1945 | | Byron Nelson (EU) | | |
| 1946 | Herman Keiser (EU) | Ben Hogan (EU) | Lloyd Mangrum (EU) | Sam Snead (EU) |
| 1947 | Jimmy Demaret (EU) | Jim Ferrier (AUS) | Lew Worsham (EU) | Fred Daly (IRL. N) |
| 1948 | Claude Harmon (EU) | Ben Hogan (EU) | Ben Hogan (EU) | Henry Cotton (ING) |
| 1949 | Sam Snead (EU) | Sam Snead (EU) | Cary Middlecoff (EU) | Bobby Locke (RSA) |
| 1950 | Jimmy Demaret (EU) | Chandler Harper (EU) | Ben Hogan (EU) | Bobby Locke (RSA) |
| 1951 | Ben Hogan (EU) | Sam Snead (EU) | Ben Hogan (EU) | Max Faulkner (ING) |
| 1952 | Sam Snead (EU) | Jim Turnesa (EU) | Julius Boros (EU) | Bobby Locke (RSA) |
| 1953 | Ben Hogan (EU) | Walter Burkemo (EU) | Ben Hogan (EU) | Ben Hogan (EU) |
| 1954 | Sam Snead (EU) | Chick Harbert (EU) | Ed Furgol (EU) | Peter Thomson (AUS) |
| 1955 | Cary Middlecoff (EU) | Doug Ford (EU) | Jack Fleck (EU) | Peter Thomson (AUS) |
| 1956 | Jack Burke Jr. (EU) | Jack Burke Jr. (EU) | Cary Middlecoff (EU) | Peter Thomson (AUS) |
| 1957 | Doug Ford (EU) | Lionel Hebert (EU) | Dick Mayer (EU) | Bobby Locke (RSA) |
| 1958 | Arnold Palmer (EU) | Dow Finsterwald (EU) | Tommy Bolt (EU) | Peter Thomson (AUS) |
| 1959 | Art Wall Jr. (EU) | Bob Rosburg (EU) | Billy Casper (EU) | Gary Player (RSA) |
| 1960 | Arnold Palmer (EU) | Jay Hebert (EU) | Arnold Palmer (EU) | Kel Nagle (AUS) |
| 1961 | Gary Player (RSA) | Jerry Barber (EU) | Gene Littler (EU) | Arnold Palmer (EU) |
| 1962 | Arnold Palmer (EU) | Gary Player (RSA) | Jack Nicklaus (EU) | Arnold Palmer (EU) |
| 1963 | Jack Nicklaus (EU) | Jack Nicklaus (EU) | Julius Boros (EU) | Bob Charles (N.Z) |
| 1964 | Arnold Palmer (EU) | Bobby Nichols (EU) | Ken Venturi (EU) | Tony Lema (EU) |
| 1965 | Jack Nicklaus (EU) | Dave Marr (EU) | Gary Player (RSA) | Peter Thomson (AUS) |
| 1966 | Jack Nicklaus (EU) | Al Geiberger (EU) | Billy Casper (EU) | Jack Nicklaus (EU) |
| 1967 | Gay Brewer (EU) | Don January (EU) | Jack Nicklaus (EU) | Roberto De Vicenzo (ARG) |
| 1968 | Bob Goalby (EU) | Julius Boros (EU) | Lee Trevino (EU) | Gary Player (RSA) |
| 1969 | George Archer (EU) | Raymond Floyd (EU) | Orville Moody (EU) | Tony Jacklin (EU) |
| 1970 | Billy Casper (EU) | Dave Stockton (EU) | Tony Jacklin (ING) | Jack Nicklaus (EU) |
| 1971 | Charles Coody (EU) | Jack Nicklaus (EU) | Lee Trevino (EU) | Lee Trevino (EU) |
| 1972 | Jack Nicklaus (EU) | Gary Player (RSA) | Jack Nicklaus (EU) | Lee Trevino (EU) |
| 1973 | Tommy Aaron (EU) | Jack Nicklaus (EU) | Johnny Miller (EU) | Tom Weiskopf (EU) |
| 1974 | Gary Player (RSA) | Lee Trevino (EU) | Hale Irwin (EU) | Gary Player (RSA) |
| 1975 | Jack Nicklaus (EU) | Jack Nicklaus (EU) | Lou Graham (EU) | Tom Watson (EU) |
| 1976 | Raymond Floyd (EU) | Dave Stockton (EU) | Jerry Pate (EU) | Johnny Miller (EU) |
| 1977 | Tom Watson (EU) | Lanny Wadkins (EU) | Hubert Green (EU) | Tom Watson (EU) |
| 1978 | Gary Player (RSA) | John Mahaffey (EU) | Andy North (EU) | Jack Nicklaus (EU) |
| 1979 | Fuzzy Zoeller (EU) | David Graham (AUS) | Hale Irwin (EU) | Seve Ballesteros (ESP) |
| 1980 | Seve Ballesteros (ESP) | Jack Nicklaus (EU) | Jack Nicklaus (EU) | Tom Watson (EU) |
| 1981 | Tom Watson (EU) | Larry Nelson (EU) | David Graham (AUS) | Bill Rogers (EU) |
| 1982 | Craig Stadler (EU) | Raymond Floyd (EU) | Tom Watson (EU) | Tom Watson (EU) |
| 1983 | Seve Ballesteros (ESP) | Hal Sutton (EU) | Larry Nelson (EU) | Tom Watson (EU) |
| 1984 | Ben Crenshaw (EU) | Lee Trevino (EU) | Fuzzy Zoeller (EU) | Seve Ballesteros (ESP) |
| 1985 | Bernhard Langer (ALE) | Hubert Green (EU) | Andy North (EU) | Sandy Lyle (ESC) |
| 1986 | Jack Nicklaus (EU) | Bob Tway (EU) | Raymond Floyd (EU) | Greg Norman (AUS) |
| 1987 | Larry Mize (EU) | Larry Nelson (EU) | Scott Simpson (EU) | Nick Faldo (ING) |
| 1988 | Sandy Lyle (ESC) | Jeff Sluman (EU) | Curtis Strange (EU) | Seve Ballesteros (ESP) |
| 1989 | Nick Faldo (ING) | Payne Stewart (EU) | Curtis Strange (EU) | Mark Calcavecchia (EU) |
| 1990 | Nick Faldo (ING) | Wayne Grady (AUS) | Hale Irwin (EU) | Nick Faldo (ING) |
| 1991 | Ian Woosnam (GAL) | John Daly (EU) | Payne Stewart (EU) | Ian Baker-Finch (AUS) |
| 1992 | Fred Couples (EU) | Nick Price (ZIM) | Tom Kite (EU) | Nick Faldo (ING) |
| 1993 | Bernhard Langer (ALE) | Paul Azinger (EU) | Lee Janzen (EU) | Greg Norman (AUS) |
| 1994 | José María Olazábal (ESP) | Nick Price (ZIM) | Ernie Els (RSA) | Nick Price (ZIM) |
| 1995 | Ben Crenshaw (2) | Steve Elkington (AUS) | Corey Pavin (EU) | John Daly (EU) |
| 1996 | Nick Faldo (ING) | Mark Brooks (EU) | Steve Jones (EU) | Tom Lehman (EU) |
| 1997 | Tiger Woods (EU) | Davis Love III (EU) | Ernie Els (RSA) | Justin Leonard (EU) |
| 1998 | Mark O’Meara (EU) | Vijay Singh (FIJ) | Lee Janzen (EU) | Mark O’Meara (EU) |
| 1999 | José María Olazábal (ESP) | Tiger Woods (EU) | Payne Stewart (EU) | Paul Lawrie (ESC) |
| 2000 | Vijay Singh (FIJ) | Tiger Woods (EU) | Tiger Woods (EU) | Tiger Woods (EU) |
| 2001 | Tiger Woods (EU) | David Toms (EU) | Retief Goosen (RSA) | David Duval (EU) |
| 2002 | Tiger Woods (EU) | Rich Beem (EU) | Tiger Woods (EU) | Ernie Els (RSA) |
| 2003 | Mike Weir (CAN) | Shaun Micheel (EU) | Jim Furyk (EU) | Ben Curtis (EU) |
| 2004 | Phil Mickelson (EU) | Vijay Singh (FIJ) | Retief Goosen (RSA) | Todd Hamilton (EU) |
| 2005 | Tiger Woods (EU) | Phil Mickelson (EU) | Michael Campbell (N.Z) | Tiger Woods (EU) |
| 2006 | Phil Mickelson (EU) | Tiger Woods (EU) | Geoff Ogilvy (AUS) | Tiger Woods (EU) |
| 2007 | Zach Johnson (EU) | Tiger Woods (EU) | Ángel Cabrera (ARG) | Pádraig Harrington (IRL) |
| 2008 | Trevor Immelman (RSA) | Pádraig Harrington (IRL) | Tiger Woods (EU) | Pádraig Harrington (IRL) |
| 2009 | Ángel Cabrera (ARG) | Yang Yong-eun (COR. S) | Lucas Glover (EU) | Stewart Cink (EU) |
| 2010 | Phil Mickelson (EU) | Martin Kaymer (ALE) | Graeme McDowell (IRL. N) | Louis Oosthuizen (RSA) |
| 2011 | Charl Schwartzel (RSA) | Keegan Bradley (EU) | Rory McIlroy (IRL. N) | Darren Clarke (IRL. N) |
| 2012 | Bubba Watson (EU) | Rory McIlroy (IRL. N) | Webb Simpson (EU) | Ernie Els (RSA) |
| 2013 | Adam Scott (AUS) | Jason Dufner (EU) | Justin Rose (ING) | Phil Mickelson (EU) |
| 2014 | Bubba Watson (EU) | Rory McIlroy (IRL. N) | Martin Kaymer (ALE) | Rory McIlroy (IRL. N) |
| 2015 | Jordan Spieth (EU) | Jason Day (AUS) | Jordan Spieth (EU) | Zach Johnson (EU) |
| 2016 | Danny Willett (ING) | Jimmy Walker (EU) | Dustin Johnson (EU) | Henrik Stenson (SUE) |
| 2017 | Sergio García (ESP) | Justin Thomas (EU) | Brooks Koepka (EU) | Jordan Spieth (EU) |
| 2018 | Patrick Reed (EU) | Brooks Koepka (EU) | Brooks Koepka (EU) | Francesco Molinari (ITA) |
| 2019 | Tiger Woods (EU) | Brooks Koepka (EU) | Gary Woodland (EU) | Shane Lowry (IRL) |
| 2020 | Dustin Johnson (EU) | Collin Morikawa (EU) | Bryson DeChambeau (EU) | – |
| 2021 | Hideki Matsuyama (JAP) | Phil Mickelson (EU) | Jon Rahm (ESP) | Collin Morikawa (EU) |
| 2022 | Scottie Scheffler (EU) | Justin Thomas (EU) | Matt Fitzpatrick (ING) | Cameron Smith (AUS) |
| 2023 | Jon Rahm (ESP) | Brooks Koepka (EU) | Wyndham Clark (EU) | Brian Harman (EU) |
| 2024 | Scottie Scheffler (EU) | Xander Schauffele (EU) | Bryson DeChambeau (EU) | Xander Schauffele (EU) |
| 2025 | Rory McIlroy (IRL. N) | Scottie Scheffler (EU) | J.J. Spaun (EU) | Scottie Scheffler (EU) |